So I saw Rome Series 2 is out now at blockbuster.....currently working my way through in a hurry.
I am sorry but Atia is way too demonized. there's no way a woman could get ahold of another aristocrat and do such horrible things without being penalized...just my thoughts...any others?
I am sorry but Atia is way too demonized. there's no way a woman could get ahold of another aristocrat and do such horrible things without being penalized...just my thoughts...any others?
-
Re: Rome 2 is out!!!
Wed, August 22, 2007 - 11:24 AM>>Atia is way too demonized
"Atia" is a fictional character. She bears no resemblance to the historical person.
-
Re: Rome 2 is out!!!
Thu, August 23, 2007 - 12:25 PM"I am sorry but Atia is way too demonized. There's no way a woman could get ahold of another aristocrat and do such horrible things without being penalized.."
Well, as Forrest says, she doesn't resemble what we can guess about the historical Atia at all. Roman matrons of the time weren't like that. Though just a few decades later ... they most certainly were. Read up on what Julia (Octavian's daughter), or, say, Valeria Messalina or Agrippina (Nero's mother) was like. They did far more horrible things than Atia. Really though, Atia of the Julii displays a character more suited to modern Hollywood than any era of Ancient Rome. That was the main defect in the series, and in almost all depictions of ancient Rome. All of the old 50s Hollywood epics were like this. So was I, Claudius, really. I thought Fellini's homo-erotic Satyricon (of all things I have seen) best captured Roman character. -
-
Re: Rome 2 is out!!!
Thu, August 23, 2007 - 3:34 PMOne thing I did like about the "Rome" series: It made a serious effort to depict the lives of ordinary citizens, the lower- and middle-class people (Titus Pullo and Lucius Vorenus) who marched in Rome's armies . . . Generally, these things focus on what the likes of Julius Caesar and Marcus Antonius were doing . . . Here, even slaves sometimes get to make a commentary, which is very much in the spirit of Roman comedy. -
-
Re: Rome 2 is out!!!
Fri, August 24, 2007 - 1:03 AMI agree; the characterizations of Pulio and Vorenus was quite good, and it was a nice touch showing the big events through the eyes of ordinary people. I also thought it was cute how they baked in some fairly Roman racial politics (aka, people making fun of Vorenus' celto-germanic carrot top). While it is the doings of the great men who come down to us in history, Rome really was the first middle class society (or one of the first anyway), so it's only right to show the big events through such eyes. One might contrast the class mobility of old Rome with that of modern societies.
-
-